Golf Betting Club Review – Long-Term Profits from Golf Tips?

Obviously not pretty reading! There is no denying that the service hit a considerable drawdown almost as soon as I started following. You can see that illustrated on the below chart.

After a 100/1 winner in the third week of tracking courtesy of Brian Campbell at the John Deere Classic, we had to wait another six months for an outright winner to arrive in the form of Hideki Matsuyama at 25/1.

Interestingly, both these outright winners were advised as in-play bets, meaning in the entire tracking period, we did not see one pre-tournament outright winner.

Let’s look closer at the breakdown of results by pre-event and in-play:

Pre-Event

Bets	P/L (pts)	ROI
316	-137.75	-43.45%

In-Play

Bets	P/L (pts)	ROI
92	29.63	32.2%

We could look at this breakdown in one of two ways: an encouraging sign of GBC’s in-play edge or a concerning snapshot of their pre-event performance. Perhaps both are true.

The reality is, going several months without an outright winner in golf is not an extraordinary occurrence or a sign that a tipster has lost their edge.

For context, the average odds of all outright win selections was 124.41. If we remove the in-play selections, as some of these are on relatively short prices heading into the final Sunday, the average odds increase to 149.88.

This is interesting as it is higher than what we see across other golf tipsters. Something which was notable about following the service was that, particularly on the DP World Tour, there are regularly each-way selections advised with win odds north of 500 on the Betfair Exchange.

At those odds, it can feel like you are just donating away money.

Encouragingly, in their end of year review, GBC noted that these types of selections were not performing strongly and that they would be reduced in 2026.

The idea behind them was that they did not fancy the players at the front of the market, so the approach was to bet several longer priced golfers. Moving forward it appears they will be more selective with the longer priced selections.  

Final Verdict

Six months is a relatively short timeframe from which to draw firm conclusions about any golf tipster, and that caveat is particularly important here. With average win odds approaching 150/1 on pre-event selections, extended losing runs certainly come with the territory.

In reality, the sample size simply isn’t large enough to judge the service fairly.

That said, a loss of over 108 points and an ROI of -29.64% is not something we can simply gloss over. The absence of a single pre-event outright winner across the entire tracking period was the defining story of the trial period.

There are reasons to be cautiously optimistic.

The in-play selections demonstrated a genuine edge, and GBC have shown self-awareness in acknowledging that their ultra-long-priced selections underperformed and committing to a more selective approach going forward.

That adaptability is an encouraging trait in a tipster and one we regularly see across tipsters who have been successful over time. As markets adapt, so too must those betting on them.

On balance, I would not discourage anyone from giving GBC a look — particularly those comfortable with the volatility that comes with long-odds golf betting.

But equally, I cannot offer an enthusiastic endorsement off the back of this trial alone. A neutral recommendation is therefore appropriate here.

If you want to give it a try – get 10% off here.